Audit methodology
The detailed description of how audits are carried out. What is recorded at every change in holdings, what the daily control covers and how the full quarterly physical inventory works.
Control at every change in holdings
Every change in holdings is physically checked and documented immediately. For deposits, withdrawals, transfers between accounts, handovers or other movements of holdings, the bars and coins concerned are physically counted and reconciled with the storage data.
-
Type of precious metal and product
Gold, silver, platinum or palladium, in each case as a bar or a coin.
-
Number of pieces
The number of pieces concerned is counted, not taken from the documents.
-
Weight and fine weight
Both are recorded, because only the fine weight describes the actual precious metal content.
-
Manufacturer or mint
The origin of every piece is recorded.
-
Condition and integrity
Packaging, seals and visible condition are checked and noted.
-
Related documents
Storage, movement and transport documents are allocated to the movement.
Which of these details are recorded in an individual case depends on the product. Every newly received piece undergoes an authenticity check before it is stored.
Daily holdings control
Even on days without any change in holdings, the holdings are documented and checked daily. The basis is the most recently physically confirmed holding and the storage movements recorded since then.
-
What is reconciled daily
Holdings data, storage vouchers, movement documents, vault access logs and any available security and safeguarding records. This continuously checks whether changes in holdings have been fully recorded and documented in a traceable way.
-
What the daily control is not
It does not mean that all bars and coins are counted in full again every day. The physical count takes place at every change in holdings for the pieces concerned, and in addition as part of the full quarterly physical inventory.
Full quarterly physical inventory
Once a quarter, all client holdings at all storage locations are physically counted in full and reconciled with the storage data.
In addition to the immediate physical control at changes in holdings and the daily documented holdings control, a full physical inventory is carried out at all storage locations every quarter. All bars and coins included on the inventory reference date are physically counted, recorded by type of precious metal and fine weight, and reconciled with the holdings data of the warehouse management system and the relevant storage documents.
-
Scope
Gold, silver, platinum and palladium in the form of bars and coins, at all storage locations.
-
Characteristics checked
Type of precious metal, type of product, number of pieces, weight and fine weight.
-
Context
The quarterly inventory supplements the ongoing controls in day-to-day storage operations with a regular, full physical stocktake. The result is included in the audit report for the month concerned.
Who is responsible for what
In the past, the entire audit lay with one body. Today the tasks are separated, so that each level can deliver what it is intended for.
| Body | Task | Result |
|---|---|---|
| SOOS GmbH, storage operations | Physical count at every change in holdings, authenticity check, keeping of storage records | Storage and movement documentation |
| GVS, internal control function | Daily holdings control, quarterly inventory, reconciliation with the client storage agreement volumes | Monthly audit reports |
| External auditors | On-site spot checks following a documented, risk-based procedure | One report per external storage audit |
| Notary | Documentary and arithmetical reconciliation of the storage agreement numbers and fine weights at the quarter-end reference date | Notarised individual confirmation on request |
For details: Monthly audit reports · External storage audits · Notarised individual confirmation
Limits of the control
An audit system is only worth as much as your knowledge of what it does not cover. That is why this is stated here too.
-
GVS is not independent
The monthly audit reports are an internal control. Because of the personnel link with SOOS GmbH, GVS is not an external auditing firm that is independent both financially and in terms of personnel. The audit report is therefore not an audit opinion in the sense of an independent statutory audit.
-
External audits are spot checks
The external auditor checks selected items at selected locations, not the entire holdings. That is the purpose of a spot check. If anything irregular is found, the auditor may extend the scope of the audit appropriately.
-
The notary does not count
The notarised individual confirmation is a documentary and arithmetical reconciliation. The notary does not carry out a physical count of holdings, any authenticity check or any on-site storage audit.
The basis of the internal control is a written GVS audit manual. It governs the audit plan, daily checklists, data access rights, documentation obligations, the handling of discrepancies, signing authority, report format and archiving periods.
Questions about the audit methodology?
We are happy to explain how an individual audit works and what is stated in an audit report. This applies even if you do not yet have storage with us.
Precious metals are subject to price fluctuations. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future developments. This is not tax or investment advice.